CV Leftovers

There are very few quality REO listings around the 92130 – the houses tend to be ones that aren’t worth keeping.  If there are homeowners struggling to keep up with their payments, they would be smart to short sale in the next few months, because the exemption from debt-relief taxation expires at the end of 2012:

Healthy, Steady Housing Market

When I say, “the inventory is thin”, it really means that the demand for good-looking-properties-that-are-priced-reasonably is healthy.  While that would seem obvious in any market, it is worth repeating when all you hear is how bad the real estate market is from the mainstream media. 

We have also seen that there is a relationship between inventory and sales/pricing. 

When there are fewer houses on the market, buyers feel pressed to gobble up the ones that are available – and end up paying whatever it takes.  Flash back to 2003 to remember the max-frenzy conditions!

Here are the comparisons of the total number of detached listings/number of solds between January 1st and October 31st in North SD County Coastal (La Jolla to Carlsbad).  There isn’t a direct connection between them – some sold this year were listed last year – but the TL/S-ratio trend is worth watching:

Year Total Listings Solds TL/S Ratio
1999
4,807
2,762
1.74
2000
4,410
2,787
1.58
2001
5,291
2,514
2.10
2002
5,373
3,139
1.71
2003
4,753
3,299
1.44
2004
4,698
2,891
1.63
2005
4,935
2,593
1.90
2006
5,496
2,204
2.49
2007
4,829
2,180
2.22
2008
4,687
1,799
2.61
2009
4,521
1,791
2.52
2010
4,717
2,072
2.28
2011
4,460
2,162
2.06

This year we’ve had the fewest listings since 2000, and more sales since 2007, the height of easy financing. Yet the balance feels relatively healthy, and like the old Jim Ratio of actives-to-pendings, I think we can say that a 2.0 TL/S-ratio is about right.

(For those with MLS access who are checking, because Sandicor deletes withdrawn listings from previous years, I deleted them from all years – there were only 211 this year. The expireds and cancelled listings are included.)

While it feels like there are very few good deals available, does it mean that there has been pressure on pricing lately?  Let’s compare detached sales and pricing in the same January 1st-to-October 31st period of this year, to last year:

Town or Area Zip Code Sales 2010/2011 Avg $/sf 2010/2011
Cardiff 92007
55/73
$483/$469
Carlsbad NW 92008
112/137
$324/$313
Carlsbad SE 92009
446/429
$269/$253
Carlsbad NE 92010
80/123
$260/$238
Carlsbad SW 92011
173/155
$295/$292
Del Mar 92014
78/137
$619/$680
Encinitas 92024
328/305
$356/$352
La Jolla 92037
214/228
$630/$595
RSF 67+91
161/171
$433/$432
Solana Bch 92075
73/57
$538/$560
Carmel Vly 92130
352/348
$342/$330
Total All
2,072/2,162
$378/$378

With the exception of the Del Mar explosion, those numbers look as steady as possible.

2012 Forecasts

Hat tip to Mr. T for sending in this article from money.cnn.com:

Last year the economic forecasting firm Fiserv predicted that home values would sink around 5% in 2011, and that prices in three-quarters of the nation’s major metro areas would fall. The bad news is, the firm wasn’t that far off the mark.

The good news: In the coming year, Fiserv thinks 95% of the 384 metro areas it tracks will see prices rise.

Don’t expect the market to move much beyond first gear, though. The median expectation among more than 100 economists and real estate pros surveyed by MacroMarkets is that home values will inch ahead by a mere 0.25%, compared to their 2011 median forecast decline of 2.8%. They also foresee annualized gains through 2015 of just 1.1%, as the real estate market slowly works its way through a mountain of foreclosures.

Those foreclosures will continue to weigh on the market. According to Core- Logic, there are 5.4 million homes that are for sale or part of the market’s “shadow inventory” — which includes bank-owned properties, homes in the foreclosure pipeline that haven’t hit the market yet, or properties where owners are seriously behind on payments.

To put that in perspective, Freddie Mac forecasts that only 4.8 million homes will be purchased in all of 2012. A market with six months of inventory is considered healthy. That there’s more than a year’s worth of housing stock now tells you what a tough slog this will still be. “It’s analogous to a flood,” says Mark Fleming, CoreLogic’s chief economist. “The water is very deep in the living room, but it’s no longer getting deeper and is starting to recede.

Helping that process along will be low-interest-rate mortgages that are expected to remain cheap. Jay Brinkmann, chief economist at the Mortgage Bankers Association, says the 4.2% rate on a 30-year fixed rate in late October might not last long. Still, he expects the 30-year fixed mortgage rate to stay below 5% throughout 2012.

Buyers: Downsize the dream.  For those gearing up to make a purchase, 2012 could be a great opportunity, what with cheap prices, low borrowing rates, and little competition among prospective bidders.

Before you take the plunge, remember that the price you pay matters, as does your ability to easily resell that home down the road.

This means it’s best to focus on smaller properties in your area near restaurants and retail. McMansions of at least 2,600 square feet, which were the ideal in the boom years, are coveted by a mere 18% of households today, according to a recent survey by Trulia. And that figure could fall even more.

A separate survey by the National Association of Home Builders found that home-construction firms expect U.S. houses to average 2,152 square feet in 2015 — down 10% from last year.

Some of this is attributable to the lingering effects of the past recession, which has eaten into housing budgets. But there’s also a permanent change at play. “Baby boomers are trading down. They don’t need the McMansion, and they don’t want to drive as much,” says Trulia chief economist Jed Kolko.

Sellers: Price it right. The longer you can wait for prices to stabilize in your area and for demand to pick up, the less likely you’ll need to entertain low-ball offers. If you have to make a move in 2012, though, the trick will be to price your home correctly out of the gate.

According to a recent national survey of real estate agents, 75% of homeowners believe their house is worth more than what agents put the fair market value at, and nearly one in two homeowners still overestimate their home’s value by more than 10%.

Meanwhile, Trulia reports that about one in four homes in its database has gone through at least one price reduction, and the average price cut for those homes is 8%.

Joe Magdziarz, president of the Appraisal Institute, says you and your agent should stick with comparable sales data just within the past 90 days, as that’s what lenders expect appraisers to use.

If you don’t trust your agent’s recommendation, shell out $300 to $400 for an outside appraisal. That will be money well spent if it pushes you to list your home in sync with current market valuations and you sell faster.

Owners: Shorten your loan. Refinancing your old mortgage to a new fixed-rate loan could have you smiling for years to come. If there’s any chance you can refinance into a 15-year loan, go for it; the 3.45% rate in late October was near an all-time low. On a $250,000 mortgage, going from a 30-year mortgage at 4.2% to a 15-year loan charging 3.45% would save you $120,000 in interest over the life of the loan.

What if the added $560 monthly payment is too steep to handle? Shop for a 20-year loan. The rate is likely to be only slightly less than on a 30-year loan, but the faster payback will save you in the long run.

FHAs Are Back To $697,500 in SD

From MND:

President Barack Obama signed a bill Friday that reinstates the recently expired higher loan limits that were in effect for FHA and VA loans through December 31, 2013 but does not provide this extension to Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.  H.R. 2112 sponsored by Jack Kingston (R-GA) was approved by a House/Senate conference committee vote of 298 to 121 in the House and 70 to 30 in the Senate on Thursday and sent to the White House.  

Section 238 of the bill, The Agriculture Rural Development, Food and Drug Administration and Related Agencies Appropriation Act of 2012 returns the limit on FHA loans to the multi-tiered arrangement that existed under the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008, provisions for which expired on October 1.  Since that date the FHA and GSE maximum has been at $625,500.   Under the restored limits the highest FHA loan available in designated high cost areas will be $729,750.  Loans written between October 1 and today’s effective date of the new legislation will not be eligible for the new limits.  Limits on VA loans will return to the levels established under the Veterans Benefits Improvement Act of 2008 which are, in some cases, higher than FHA limits.

The Senate had amended the House bill, adding the same extensions for the GSEs as FHA, but the joint conference committee rejected that change.   Instead, limits for the two government sponsored enterprises (GSEs) will be determined by the greater of the limitation in effect at the time the loan was purchased or “the limitation that was prescribed for loans originated during the period beginning on July 1, 2007 and ending on December 31, 2008, pursuant to section 201 of the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008, thus keeping the maximums on a range from $417,000 to $625,500 depending on local market conditions.

The new legislation also sets an annual fee for loans guaranteed by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae.  This fee is in the amount of 15 basis points on the outstanding principal balance of the loan and is “independent of any guarantee fees upfront on ongoing, charged to the borrower, and the premium loan fee shall not be affected by changes in guarantee fees.”  The fee, according to the bill, is expected to achieve an annual income of $300 million in revenue which “shall be used to pay for costs associated with maintaining loan limits established under this section. (who pays this?)

The administration and many congressional Democrats had opposed the higher limits for FHA because this might increase FHA’s market share at the same time the government was trying to encourage private lending.  Others were opposed to excluding the GSEs from the increase, also because of the potential impact on the FHA share.

The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) was quick to applaud the bill, issuing a press release from Chairman Bob Nielsen that says in part, “We commend congressional leaders in both parties and each chamber of Congress for taking this action to boost overall mortgage liquidity in the marketplace, create jobs, and provide home owners and home buyers with safe and affordable financing.  “Restoring the higher FHA loan limits will help to stabilize home values, provide constancy while private investors re-enter the market, and enable millions of creditworthy consumers to get home loans with the best mortgage rates and lowest fees and downpayment requirements”

 

Auction Fever

All they have to do is ditch the reserve price, and auctions would work great – have some guts!  Hat tip to AL for sending this along from the wsj.com:

Last Friday, about 60 people gathered at a 10,300-square-foot French Chateau-style home in a gated community of this wealthy suburb of Los Angeles. Nibbling on fruit salad and croissants, the visitors meandered through the home’s large kitchen, checked out the view of the rolling hills or peeked into the movie theater with stadium seating while it played “Pretty in Pink.”

They had all gathered to see this seven-bedroom, seven-bath mansion, which was rented by singer Britney Spears between roughly 2008 and 2010, sell to the highest bidder. The home had previously been on the market for as much as $10.8 million; bidding would start at $4.5 million.

“I’m starting to get butterflies,” confessed Regina Leon, who owns the home with her husband Jose “Pancho” Leon, a builder and founder of a money-order company. After several of her girlfriends mentioned they were coming by, Ms. Leon had decided at the last minute to cancel her hair appointment to stay to watch the action unfold. Mr. Leon said he wasn’t worried, though he admitted he’d gotten only about four hours of sleep the night before.

Once considered a last resort for desperate sellers or for banks unloading foreclosed properties, home auctions are increasingly being used to sell penthouse apartments, waterfront mansions and grand country estates—many of them languishing in an uncertain market after significant price cuts. At Premiere Estates Auction Co., founded 10 years ago, the average price of a home the company auctions is up nearly 40% from a year or so ago, says auctioneer Anthony Fitzgerald. Gadsden, Ala.-based auction company JP King, in business since 1915, has seen inquiries for home auctions above $10 million so far this year double from a couple of years ago, said Craig King, the company’s president. In 2010, the company had 11 inquiries for homes above $10 million; so far this year it’s had 24.

As the housing slump drags on, the carrying costs of waiting out the market have become onerous, even for the wealthiest. A seller who put a home on the market in 2009 hoping that a turnaround was on the horizon may now be realizing that it could take several years or more for the market to rebound. Taxes on a $10 million or $20 million home can run into the hundreds of thousands of dollars a year, in addition to staffing, landscaping and other upkeep. The ultra high-end of the market is particularly vulnerable: As of September, houses priced at $10 million and above declined nearly 9.5% in value from last year, according to Zillow, the online housing tracker, compared to a 4.4% decline overall.

“Eventually, even the people who have unlimited means will throw in the towel at some point,” said George Graham, the CEO of Concierge Auctions.

Some brokers warn that when a well-known mansion or estate fails to sell at auction, it can become tarnished, making it harder to sell in the future. “If you have all that hype and then it doesn’t sell, then you’ve got egg on your face,” said Jeffrey Hyland, president of Beverly Hills-based real-estate firm Hilton & Hyland.

Bob Hurwitz, a longtime Southern California broker who recently tried unsuccessfully to auction off a $45 million sculptural-style home in La Jolla known as “the Razor,” said he’s concluded the process doesn’t benefit sellers, who assume all the risk by paying marketing fees up front. (Fees can range anywhere from a couple thousand dollars to upwards of $150,000 for ultra high-end homes.) He said auctions can also turn off potential buyers who don’t want to pay an additional 8% to 12% in premiums after the sale, which can amount to a million dollars or more for an expensive home. “It just doesn’t make sense,” he said. Laura Brady, of Concierge Auctions, said most buyers are aware that all real-estate transactions involve fees, and the premiums are included in auction-sale prices, “just like real estate agent’s fees” are in a traditional sale.

Mansions and estates are frequently auctioned for much less than their previous price tags, though those price tags may have been set unrealistically high to begin with. While both art-auction houses Christie’s and Sotheby’s are affiliated with real-estate companies, neither conducts real-estate auctions in the U.S. (Both have some affiliate agencies that have auction divisions which partner with companies like Concierge and Premiere Estates.)

(more…)

Good Schools=Fewer Foreclosures?

From wsj.com:

Highly ranked school districts may have been spared the worst of the foreclosure crisis, according to a new analysis, showing that the housing crash was akin to a tornado that tore through wide swaths, but hit with particular force in certain areas.

The analysis, conducted for Developments by Location Inc., a Worcester, Mass.-based company that mines local data for businesses and consumers, looked at six months of 2011 sales data collected by RealtyTrac Inc. It showed that the percentage of foreclosure (or “real-estate-owned”) sales went down as the school ranking went up in five metro areas – Jacksonville, Fla; Atlanta; Toledo, Ohio; Stockton, Calif.; and Seattle. Higher-rated school districts also maintained higher home-sale prices, and higher home prices per square foot.

“If you are looking to buy into one of these good school districts, it is very rare to find a foreclosure,” said Location Inc.’s chief executive Andrew Schiller, an expert in demographic analysis who conducted the research with his colleague Jonathan Glick. “It’s better to just go into a normal sale.” (The five cities were chosen to provide a general market overview.)

The finding is, to a certain extent, not a surprise. Schools have long been a driver for home buyers, whether in determining location or timing. So it would make sense that school ranking could serve as a kind of proxy for measuring the damage from the foreclosure crisis.

It’s also not that foreclosure sales don’t exist in highly ranked districts; they are just much less of a factor, and the reason could be income. Stan Humphries, chief economist for real-estate data company Zillow, said that it’s “likely both educational outcomes and foreclosures are ultimately linked to income, not to each other.”

The upper tier of homeowners saw less of an impact from the housing crash than the bottom tier, according to Mr. Humphries; the top third of homes dropped 26% from the recent high point; the bottom third of homes in value fell 37%. Some sought-after neighborhoods probably saw less severe price erosion, which in turn helped sustain property taxes and protect a vital funding source for schools.

Mr. Schiller said he sees school quality as both a result and a driver of income concentrations in parts of metropolitan areas. “Once in place, the higher-quality school systems reinforce this, causing higher demand for properties there, and higher values.”

Good schools may also be one of few factors keeping buyers in certain markets today, further bolstering prices and property-tax bases in sought-after districts like Newton, Mass. and Cupertino, Calif., said Glenn Kelman, chief executive of the online brokerage Redfin. “People always want to live in those school districts,” Mr. Kelman said. “And those school districts have remained well-financed even as neighboring districts have to cut costs.”

The boom brought in all kinds of potential buyers, Mr. Kelman said, but potential buyers today “better have a damn good reason, and usually that reason is 6 years old.”

(more…)

Pin It on Pinterest