Monday, April 28th, 2008 at 2:02 PM
Potential Flip?
We’ve been waiting for the foreclosure in Davidson’s La Costa Oaks to make it to market, and it’s going to happen this week. As predicted, the list price will be around $900,000 (they’re still working on the price).
Is there a potential for flipping this?

We just saw the guy in Encinitas Ranch purchase a 3,416 sf foreclosure for $925,000 and turned it around in 30 days and sold it for close to his full price of $1,147,760 (with a back-up offer standing by).
Could we do the same?
After all, there hasn’t been a Davidson resale close under $1,000,000, and the lowest was this same floor plan that listed for $989,000 in July - and it sold the first week, closing over list at $1,007,000.
The last sale in Davidson was a 4,000 sf Plan Two that I just sold a few doors down for $1,150,000 that had all the bells and whistles. The buyers and I knew about this foreclosure, and felt their house was well worth the extra expense. But we might be the only ones, because we investigated thoroughly. A casual buyer just looking at basic stats might think the foreclosure with improvements could be worth $1,050,000 or more.
Forget the fact that the opening bid at the trustee sale was $839,393, and nobody picked it up. If this could be bought around $900,000, could you make money on a flip?
$1,080,000 Flip sales price
$ 900,000 Buy price
$ 180,000 Potential gross profit
You make all your money on the buy side - YOU HAVE TO BUY THEM RIGHT!
To buy this for $900,000 would mean that you edged in front of other buyers and nabbed it before a bidding war broke out. Tough to do on an REO property, because the banks take their time responding. But if you want to take a shot at it, I have the idea that might work. But first, let’s see if it’s worth it.
The house, built in 2005, has never been landscaped. Can you spend $20,000 or so and make it look like $100,000 invested? You can tell in the picture above that you might be able to get away with sprinklers and sod for the front yard, how about the back? From the street you can see the houses above, but once in the backyard they are mostly out of the line of sight. But with 3-4 large palms on the slope, a good-sized grass area, and a decent concrete patio you might be OK. Admittedly, you have to either know a landscaper who owed you a big favor, or a good realtor with connections!

Front Yard = $5,000
Back Yard = $20,000
Speaking of realtors, how much are closing costs?
Purchase side = $6,000
Sell side = $50,000
Closing costs = $56,000
That’s a hurdle – heck I’m practically a partner with you!
But if we assume that I can sharpen my pencil on the fees, will this work as a flipper? These homes came with granite slab counters and other upgrades, will that be enough?
Specifically, you have to nail the flooring – 18-inch diagonal travertine in entry and kitchen is preferred, plus upper-grade carpet.
Did we get lucky that the owner already did those upgrades? Nope, this is the same guy who tried to spec the house on Keeneland, and lost both to foreclosure. He cheaped out here, and only did 12-inch standard ceramic tile flooring (strike one), but he did include plantation shutters, but they are a red-ish color (strike two).
Being able to identify the deal-killers is the critical difference between flipping and flopping these days. If someone tries to flip this without changing the flooring, they’ll need a lot of luck. I’d figure $8 to $10 per square foot for travertine installation, and if you do most of the downstairs, that’ll be around $15,000 to $25,000. To have new carpet help the sale, you need to spend at least $30/yard, and let’s play it safe and say $38/yard.
Travertine = $20,000
Carpet = $10,000
You can figure that there will be other stuff too, plus the cost of sitting.
Miscellaneous = $5,000
Carrying costs = $5,000
Final tally
$1,080,000 Flip sales price
$ 121,000 Costs
$ 900,000 Buy price
$ 59,000 Net profit (before taxes)
How could you do better? Sell it yourself would be an option, but in this market buyers want to deduct the commission off what they offer. It might be better to work with an agent who can cut you a deal, and one who works to find the buyers themselves. The buyer’s agent commission here is figured at 2.5% ($27,000).
Also consider that virtually all buyers have access to what price you paid for the house. If they think that you are making a killing (you’re not, but it looks it), they either will shy away or lowball you. The guy on Heritage got very lucky to dodge this bullet.
It is much more likely that there will be multiple offers in the first week, and this will probably go to a owner-occupant in the low $900,000s.
But keep an eye out for ones that already have the upgrades installed. I’ve noticed that some of the REOs were fixed up pretty nice – some of the owners who refinanced out hundreds of thousands of dollars did put some of it back into the house.
I don’t think it’s worth the risk to make $59,000 – my rule of thumb is that there has to be an easy 10% profit, due to all the things that could go wrong.


Sounds too much like picking up pennies from infront of a steamroller. Good luck flippers.
JE | April 28th, 2008 at 11:10 pmDavidson is a very good local builder. But these floor plans to me all had major flaws. Maybe its just my taste. But if it were not for the buying frenzy 2-3 years ago many of these poor lots wedged back against a slope in back, on a through street with neighbors in tight left and right, would/should have never sold for what they did. Rock laden soil, foundation, 2 x 4′s, chicken wire and stucco, tile on the roof and vinyl windows for 900k+. Party on!
doughboy | April 28th, 2008 at 11:27 pmWhat with that small window in the front yard. I would spend a little money and enlarge it big time.
I guess the developer had extra windows from the bedroom.
worm | April 29th, 2008 at 1:31 am” Forget the fact that the opening bid at the trustee sale was $839,393, and nobody picked it up.”
This tells me that the real investors have not entered the market yet or this and many others would have been picked up on the court steps. The “flippers” may still be around and get lucky occasionally, but the smart money is not back in the game. Looks like we still have some major declines ahead……
SMC | April 29th, 2008 at 2:19 amI’m still laughing at the first post re pennies in front of a steamroller. That’s classic. I don’t laugh out loud much so that was good.
Good thoughts and analysis by Jim though. I would think about flipping it but I’m not too sure about the risk/reward equation here. The reward is not bad but I’m still a bit risk averse for this market. Probably would work though it you could get it for the price Jim indicates.
David Thoreau | April 29th, 2008 at 2:39 amThat is one ugly house, and a two car garage, I agree that the little window looks very peculiar, and look how close the side neighbors are. Jim, I think I remember you mentioning that this is your favorite builder (is that right?), is this a poor example of their usual work? Can’t imagine what could be done to make that backyard inviting short of an unlimited budget.
LR | April 29th, 2008 at 3:53 amLMAO @ the steamroller comment. Classic.
Good luck with the flip. I’d rather invest my $900k in something with a little less risk and a little more upside potential.
Genius | April 29th, 2008 at 7:12 amTravertine is an extremely pourous stone whose principal benefit was profit to the developer. One VERY fast way to qualify the quality of a McMansion is to check out if the owner sealed the travertine.
doug s. | April 29th, 2008 at 2:30 pmOne thing to keep in mind is that this house is in horrible shape. The $989k foreclosure down the street was in pretty decent shape, had a lawn in the back and had a nice view overlooking the valley. This house, in contrast is in just plain horrible shape and has a pretty crummy lot.
Chester | April 29th, 2008 at 4:28 pmIf you are forced to lower the selling price by 5%, your profit is wiped out.
south shore home buyer | April 29th, 2008 at 6:14 pmI tend to have tunnel vision when it comes to houses. I look at this house and I see a really big house crammed onto a lot that’s too small for its footprint and too close to its neighbors that I wouldn’t want to live in at any price. I have a really hard time imagining how to turn it into something I’d want to live in, so I have an equally hard time imagining how to turn it into something that anyone else would want to live in and see myself getting stuck with a house I won’t be able to sell. I’m obviously missing the kind of imagination that is needed to be a good house flipper.
GeneK | April 29th, 2008 at 7:48 pm